By
John D.
Editor's Note: The ADWEEK Salary Surrey revealed that 14.1% of the nation 's advertising employee base was unemployed during the past
year. Our editors wanted to know what it's like to be part of that statistic in today's advertising world. We located a senior copywriter in a major agency who was laid off sometime in the last year and asked him to chronicle his difficulties in finding work. Let's call him John D., a pseudonym.
John D. is one of a growing number of ad people who are laid off, merged oat or forced out of a business whose major institutions are constantly changing as shareholders and principals of major agencies seek to cash in on their equity, and clients become ever more fickle about issues of compensation, budgets and agency representation. Here in the first of a two-part series is John D. 's own story of the emotional and psychological roller coaster that being unemployed in advertising has become.
Week
No. 1. It happened mid-morning on a Wednesday. My creative director
walked into my office, closed the door, and dropped The Bomb. He said
I was being let go. Basically, it was a budget cut because of decreased
billings from a major client. He mentioned some other reasons but
I wasn't listening closely anymore. I was feeling the pain, the waves
of nausea, of remorse, of guilt, of fear, of reality. My paycheck
was going to stop. My security blanket was disappearing. My whole
life was being turned into turmoil because of a financial decision
beyond my control.
The next thing I did was stumble into the personnel director's office
to hear about my severance benefits. I got the usual after three years:
Two weeks' pay and a week's vacation. I could continue my medical
benefits. I'd be mailed my profit-sharing check within three months.
I told her I would clean out my office that weekend when I could have
some time there alone.
Then, I went to lunch and never came back.
But afterwards I felt slighted and cheated. I couldn't go around,
office to office, and say good-bye to my friends.
The first night, I felt the real fear of my situation. My family pledged
their undying support. My girlfriend vowed the same, as did several
friends.
The next day, I applied for unemployment insurance, read some want
ads, and tried to chill out. According to friends who'd been laid
off, I knew I'd be out of work for at least a month, possibly six
months or more. I had enough in the bank to survive for three months,
and thought I could generate enough income through freelance ad writing
to stay above water in the weeks ahead.
To end the week, I starting calling my network of friends at agencies
all over town, and tried to set up some interviews for the coming
week as I updated my resume. The main problem I'd have, I thought,
was selling myself aggressively to potential clients and agencies.
After 17 years in agencies, and a handful of major awards, I'd suddenly
become a commodity that needed marketing and salesmanship.
Week
No. 2. I began the week by watching a videotape at a headhunter's
office on interviewing techniques. Although filled with common-sense
advice such as, "Don't lie," "Don't bad-mouth your
former employer," etc., it also taught me the basic "Do's."
I then dropped off my portfolio at an agency where I'd once worked.
Even though I'd spent seven years there, this agency had a "drop-off'
policy for portfolios. I hate that. It's so impersonal.
Anyway, I soon realized that I needed my portfolio back to put together
some kind of self-promotion piece to accompany my resume to the dozens
of places I was soliciting for work. But my portfolio was stuck at
that agency, so I was in limbo all week.
After a few calls, I was told that the creative director would see
my book on Friday.
Lesson No. 1: The creative director resigned Friday. He never did
see my book, and I lost my first week of time.
Lesson No. 2: The next night, my girlfriend started to pull away.
She said that the "chemistry wasn't there anymore," that
she wanted to start dating others and gave me other lame excuses.
I tried to fight it, but the situation was, "Beyond my control."
I wonder if my new psychological state had affected her, or if she
just wanted out. I rationalized: If she can't stand by me now through
this crisis, she's not worth my time.
Week
No. 3. I picked up my portfolio Monday. No one there ever had the
time to see it. That really ticked me off, since I'd once worked there
for so long.
Now I could start putting together something to hook potential interviewers,
to mail to possible freelance clients, and to link my name with some
of my work. It took all week, but I finally got a four-color promotional
piece put together and had color copies made to send to the masses.
I also had my first four in-person interviews. They were all informational.
No job openings,
no job offers. But the very first interview, with an old friend, becomes
the most important one I'll have over these months. He gave me great
feedback. He told me, "You won't have any trouble getting a job.
It's just a matter of time." These were very reassuring words
to hear after what I'd been through so far.
The week ended with a mailing blitz of my promo piece and resume.
It worked instantly! I got a call late Friday to see a marketing company
on Monday for a freelance writing assignment.
Week
No. 4. Finally, things were beginning to happen. My first freelance
job was a quick turnaround ad - headlines in a few hours on Monday,
and body copy by Wednesday. Despite the pressure, it felt great to
focus my thinking on my craft with a real deadline facing me rather
than the open-ended self-imposed deadline of being re-employed.
I had three interviews Tuesday, all in the morning, and one each on
Wednesday and Thursday. On Friday, I finally got back to the first
agency where no one had had the time to see my book, and got a promise
someone would review it by Monday morning. Just a promise from an
anonymous voice, but it's an emotional victory equal to any I've had
so far.
"My
girlfriend dumped me. The emotional roller coaster is way down!"
Week
No. 5. 1 began my second month of unemployment with a freelance capabilities
presentation for a small bank account. The lead came through an art
director who's a 10-year friend. He's even generously set up a desk
and phone for me to use in his small, but growing agency. He's been
laid off a few times and is doing quite well now. And having an office
to go to daily makes it easier to deal with my situation. It also
gets me out of the house and into to town to make calls on the agencies.
We pitched the account. It went very well. We may get the business.
The emotional roller coaster is up!
That night, I had dinner with my girlfriend. She officially dumped
me. We agreed to remain ' friends.'' That means I can call her if
I want to, but I'd just be bothering her. She was so wonderful when
I was working. Now she acts like I have the plague.
The emotional roller coaster is down! Way down!
Four more interviews and a follow-up meeting on the service account
closed out the week. I've found that I'm now able to focus all my
energy on both the search for a full-time job and freelance work.
I don't feel like socializing anyway.
Footnote: My ex-agency hired a junior' copywriter right out of college.
Another person who showed promise as a writer was also promoted. With
all this, this agency still saved money over my old salary.
I even had the unusual experience of actually turning down a job offer
with an agency - they loved my work, but were offering a salary about
one-third lower than I had been making. Though it was two-thirds more
than what I'm making now (virtually nothing, it really wasn't enough
to pay all my bills. But I told them I'd like to negotiate if they're
still interested.
Week
No. 6. A few more interviews, many calls to ads in trade magazines,
and four small freelance assignments kept me very busy.
I've realized that I'm starting to make a living doing this. I can
at least support myself now, eventually make some real money at it,
and it's really been just about a month that I've been out there.
In any community, there's a freelance network and a finite number
of clients. The secret is carving out a niche in the area and working
it.
As I straddle the fence between the freelance world and the agency
world, I look down and see that the grass is green on both sides.
I know I'd still prefer the security, regular salary, and social life
of the agency side. After all, it's been all I've known for 17 years.
But until that happens, I've got to walk the fence and pick up work
from the freelance side to pay the bills.
The week ends with my friend and me landing the bank account. It's
ironic. When I worked in agencies and a new account would come in,
I'd think of what I could create for the agency, the client and my
book. Now, I think both of how many mortgage payments I can make with
this account as well as what I can do to help their business.
Week No 7. What a depressing weekend! I paid out thousands of dollars
for my two mortgages, credit cards, etc. - with no money coming in
yet and the severance money having run out.
Only four working days because of a holiday, but eight interviews.
The highlight of the week was not getting a freelance assignment from
a possible client, but having her ask me out on a date! The lowlight
of the week, and the entire unemployment period, was having my car
towed during an interview. I only blamed myself. A $110 mistake in
judgment. I tried to park at a meter in a commercial truck zone, instead
of paying a few bucks to park in a garage.
We also presented the concepts for our bank ad account. The client
received them very well. It's a model account. We're dealing directly
with the president of the company; he's open-minded and bright. A
rare find in the client world after all the turkeys I've worked with.
The week ended with an excellent interview at an agency that I first
spoke to in January, three months before the fateful day. Another
agency also showed interest in me for a full-time position. Both would
let me know within a few weeks. It looks like if I'm meant to be fully
employed again soon, it will happen this month. If not, I feel more
confident freelancing.
Week
No. 8. No interviews this week. I've had about 30 so far, and have
hit virtually every agency in town. Now, it's a matter of waiting
for the shoe to drop somewhere. Monday and Tuesday, I did two freelance
quickies. During the rest of the week, I worked with my art director
friend on our account. It's a fun campaign that will be both visible
and successful for our client.
Late in the week, I take another roller coaster ride on the Emotion
Express. Thursday, I found out some friends were laid off at one agency
that had shown promise as a place for me to go to work. Scratch that
one. But Friday, I was told by another friend that I'd be called back
for the second round at another agency. Up and down she goes, where
she stops, no one knows.
"The
week ends on another ironic note-my first freelance check bounces."
Week
No. 9. The second month of going it alone began with finishing the
big project for our bank account. I still pursued new leads in the
freelance market, and got two calls on Thursday for possible projects.
One will be an industrial video and accompanying brochure; the budget
is quite generous and once completed, would pay all my bills for one
month! Freelancing pays well if the clients are big enough. But the
work is still very sporadic.
The follow-up interview came on Friday. I know this agency likes low-key
people, which fits my personality. I came off confident, but not cocky.
The good news: The interview went well and I seemed to click with
the interviewer, my possible art director. The bad news: An offer
has already been made to another writer. If it isn't accepted, I'll
be called back again. More good news, though: The agency held onto
my portfolio to show it to someone else there.
This interview was typical of most. Whether it's informational or
a possible job offer, the tone is always set by the interviewer. If
he/she is rushed and just wants to glance quickly through my book,
I rush them through it. If not, I'll take my time and explain the
strategies behind each print campaign, TV spot, and my radio reel.
In reality, all interviews become a stage for exposing one's self
to someone's eyes.
The week ends on another ironic note- my first freelance check bounces.
Week
No. 10. This week went pretty quickly. The first few days were spent
overseeing the final touches of the bank account that breaks next
week. I also had a few meetings with freelance clients that could
be the tips of two icebergs. One company has a pool of freelance writers
it relies on, but I seem to be well-suited to one of their food clients.
If they like what I deliver next week, I might do a lot of business
with them.
The second client was a department in a large agency that hires freelancers
for its writing assignments. The art director asked me to work with
him on one project. And the account manager/department head said the
magic words to me that all freelancers love to hear: "monthly
retainer."
A follow-up call to an agency that had showed interest received the
standard reply: "We've hired a writer who doesn't have your amount
of experience, but we think he/she can do the job." This seems
to be the latest trend. Agencies are hiring younger, less expensive
writers to fill their openings, and save money. So Destiny is dealing
me a freelance hand to play. I'm playing it pretty well, now, but
still think that the offer from an agency will happen any day. I still
have two possibilities in the works.
Week
No. 11. This week was busy, but uneventful. There were no interviews,
since I've now exhausted my immediate possibilities and am still waiting
for feedback from several other possibilities.
However, I attended the grand opening for my bank account, after seeing
all our posters.
I also took a factory tour for the video script I'm to write, did
some conceptual work for a new product with my art director friend,
and worked at home one day.
"If
I can sell my condo, my debt will be erased-the roller coaster is
up!"
Week
No. 12. At the end of three months of freelancing, it now seems that
this is where I'm destined to be. Or at least until one of the agencies
I'm talking to makes up its mind to include me in its plans.
Unemployment does have at least one advantage, though. The silver
lining in this cloud that's been hanging over me is that it may help
me get rid of a condo in a city where I once worked. I've had a negative
cash flow of $500 monthly between my mortgage and the rent for the
past three years. Now, I may be able to sell the property at its current
devalued rate, have the mortgage insurance pay off the difference,
have the renter buy the place, and erase a big monthly debt-all in
one fell swoop.
It looks like my luck is definitely on the rise. The roller coaster
is up, temporarily.
Week
No. 13. This week was a prolific one - busy with writing projects.
It started with an input meeting for more bank work. Writing the second
wave of ads and brochures consumed the next few days.
Midweek, I met with another client to review the industrial video
outline with the chairman of the company. The rest of the time was
spent writing the 8-minute script.
There was no response this week to any full-time jobs I've been pursuing,
but some friends referred a headhunter to me about a possible position
in a large company's in-house creative department. Though they're
offering less money than I wanted, I'm getting to the point now after
almost three months of work to take the best offer I can get. On the
other hand, if I wait for the "right job" (since I know
it's just a matter of time), I can possibly make a lot more. And be
a lot happier.
A positive step towards selling my condo in another city: My renter
seems interested in buying the condo, but at its current devalued
price. He said he'd know for sure in a few months.
Week
No. 14. My three-month anniversary is this week. To date, my mental
attitude has improved tremendously.
My outlook is still positive. My work load is picking up. My checking
account balance is holding steady. And my social life is on the upswing.
I still think something will shake out soon.
Monday, I called two agencies I've been pursuing. Both creative directors
are away for two weeks.
Tuesday, I got a lead through a headhunter for a writing job. Ironically,
it was the one I turned down two months ago because the salary was
too low.
Week
No. 15. This was my best week yet. It began with a long interview
for a writing position. Halfway' through it, my interviewer brought
in a higher authority to discuss a possible position in another group.
When they both told me that many members of their creative staff had
started as freelancers there, it opened an option I hadn't considered.
If I could start on a part-time basis and get a good feel for the
people and the company, it could very well lead to a full-time job.
We spoke a few days later about a monthly fee and an arrangement that
would allow me to continue with other projects while still working
for them. It will be decided next week.
The next day, I met with an entrepreneur about writing a catalog for
her new company. Though other writers were going to be considered,
I won the job after showing my portfolio-another boost to my confidence
level.
Week No. 16. The two creative directors I've been pursuing returned
to their offices. One can't be reached. The other tells me very disappointing
news; he's hired someone else. It was a long shot, but I'm still upset.
It was an account and an agency I wanted to work for. Oh, well, que
sara sara!
Anyway, I've now shifted gears and become higher tech. Though I'm
computer literate, I wasn't on a Macintosh. So I took a lesson and
rented one for a month to complete two big projects that will be produced
on the Mac. It's an incredibly easy and more user-friendly tool to
work with than others.
I worked at home all week on the Mac. In fact, I'm now writing two
projects at once, working about 6 hours a day on the computer - a
lot more writing than one would do in a typical agency.
Weeks
No. 17 and 18. 1 worked these two weeks in the large in-house ad agency
I'd spoken to earlier. It was flattering to be called in as a hired
gun for my broadcast expertise and creative input. In this situation,
there seemed to be a refreshing absence of agency politics.
"I've
never worked so hard or so much. I love it! It keeps my sanity in
check."
I
basically camped out in the agency's offices for the whole two weeks.
The ant director and I created a full campaign with radio, TV and
print ads.
At night, I continued to work another few hours to complete some other
freelance projects. I've never worked so hard or so much. I love it!
It keeps my sanity in check.
Big dilemma - they like me enough to want me full-time. But now, I'm
getting used to the freedom of freelance, and may not want to give
it up. I would like to freelance for them, though. Am I crazy, or
what?
As my fourth month ends, here are my thoughts: I'm more comfortable
than ever. I keep pursuing full-time jobs, but can now better accept
the daily rejection and disappointment that follows each interview.
I've made enough money to meet my monthly financial commitments for
now. I have a new girlfriend who's very supportive, giving and sweet.
I've adjusted to this uneasy world of professional uncertainty-with
only a one-week window on my future projects. But I still would prefer
a full-time job somewhere.
Postscript.
Since this diary was submitted, I've experienced "an inner calm."
I've worked for two agencies on site freelancing for two weeks each,
so I spend less time pursuing assignments and more time doing them.
I was not able to sell my condo.
As lucrative as my current work may be, it's still not equal to earning
a regular salary with benefits. But a few opportunities for full-time
jobs are on the horizon.
One of the agencies I've freelanced for is now talking about a full-time
position and another job offer is in the works.
When I accept an offer from either of these, my roller-coaster ride
on the Emotion Express will finally end. But these months have been
the most trying transitional period of both my career and my life.